There are a lot of people having tough conversations in real estate right now. Anytime things are shifting, its worth a pause to do some math and decide what works for you and what it is that you need to be true to be comfortable moving forward. A lot of the people I talk with have done that math, and they’ve landed in one of two places.
Homes here cost enough that the usual path, buy a house and live in it or visit it, doesn’t pencil out the way it once might have. So some people start looking at land, with the idea of building something that fits their budget and their plans. And others start looking at a second home as something that should earn its keep: a few weeks of rental income, a winter ski weekend booked by strangers, a way to make the place less of a pull and more of a balance.
Those sound like different conversations. One is about dirt and the other is about guests. But they’re the same question underneath: what is this property for? And both of them offer different rules of engagement, but both end up on a town’s desk, and sometimes on a ballot, because a town and its full-time residents get a say in what a property is allowed to be.
That’s why they’re in the same essay.
Who comes through the door
The Lakes Region has always had more than one kind of resident. There are people who live here and people who come for a stretch. What’s changed is how many forms the stretch takes.
The household that rents a place on the water for a week in July might never come back. The group that books a long weekend to ski at King Pine, Abenaki, or Gunstock might be here again next February, or might not. Some houses rent only in summer. Or only in winter. Plenty of short-term rentals run year round. A second home used solely by its owners feels different from one that’s rented most weeks, and a house that’s both looks different again.
Here’s the thing: it’s less about which months a house is occupied and more about who is occupying it, and whether that’s the same group of folks over and over again or even just twice.
A second home has a household attached to it. They come back. By the third visit the neighbors know the car, the dog, and whether they’re the kind who waves. A rental might host a different household every few days, in any month. Plenty of those guests are wonderful. But nobody on the road gets to know them. When the music runs late, or the driveway hasn’t been plowed before a Friday arrival, there’s no one to walk over and say hey. There’s a number on an app.
I’m not here to tell you short-term rentals are good or bad. They’re part of life here now, and a lot of people rely on them. But they have effects worth thinking through, and those effects don’t all show up in the same place.
The economic effects cut both ways. Rental income helps an owner carry a house they love and keep it maintained. Visitors spend at restaurants, marinas, farm stands, and ski area lodges, and the people who clean, repair, paint, and plow make a living when a house is in use. At the same time, when a house that might have been someone’s year-round home becomes a rental, the pool of homes for people who want to live here shifts. What a house is worth starts to depend partly on what it can earn.
The environmental effects are quieter and easier to overlook. A lake, a shoreline, and a narrow road were sized, in a lot of ways, for a certain number of people at a certain intensity. A septic system designed around a certain number of bedrooms meets a house that sleeps more than that, sometimes multiple times in a given month. There are more boats in summer, more cars on slick roads in winter, more trash on a Sunday than the transfer station was built for. There are more people on the water who have never been told where the loon nests or how far a wake carries. None of that belongs to rentals alone. A house used heavily by its owners carries the same load, and a well-managed rental, with guests who’ve been told how things work here, can handle it as well as any. The variable is intensity and awareness, not whether anyone is paying.
And the cultural effects are the ones that don’t fit in a spreadsheet. A town runs on people who show up, who know each other, who can be called. Every change in who is present, and for how long, changes what the town can do and what it feels like to live in.
This is where I’d put some weight on anyone who owns here and isn’t here all the time. Whether it’s a second home you love, a rental you manage from three hours away, or both, be part of the town. Learn the name of the person who plows your road. Introduce yourself to the neighbor who lives here year round. Buy something at the hardware store. Come to a planning board meeting if you can; it’s the best education available in the place you own a piece of. Leave a number with a neighbor and mean it. If you rent your house, decide who in town is the person the neighbors call, and make it a person. A number on an app is not a neighbor.
None of that is hard. It just takes deciding that owning here means more than holding the deed and scheduling the cleaning crew.
Where the rules stand
All of the above are various parts of why towns are talking about rules right now. When I reached out to town surveyors and administrators, the picture was consistent. Most towns have nothing formal on the books about short-term rentals…yet. A few do. A lot of them have active plans to change that. I’m not naming towns, because the list changes by the month, and the politics of this question are ever-changing.
The questions on the table vary. Does the owner live in the house? How many nights a year can it be rented? How many cars fit in the driveway? Is a house rented most weeks of the year still a house, or something closer to a small business? Reasonable people land in different places, and the debates aren’t only about money. They’re about what each town wants to feel like, and what it wants to be able to count on.
Zoning changes in New Hampshire are decided by local voters, often at a town meeting in March, so what gets drafted this winter could be on a ballot by spring. If you own here but don’t maintain residency here, you generally can’t vote at town meeting. But planning board and zoning hearings are public, and that’s where these rules take shape.
If you’re thinking about buying a home you’d rent part of the time, that changes the order of operations. What’s allowed belongs at the start of the search, not the end. A rule that doesn’t exist today may exist by the time you close, or by the time you sell. Do your own due diligence, because this is a moving target and no article, including this one, substitutes for it. Just as important, work with an agent who understands not only how things work but what questions to ask and when to ask them: before you fall for a house, not after you’ve written an offer. If you’re already working with someone, ask how they’re approaching it. If you’re not, I’m happy to talk.
Land asks the same question from the ground up
For the people looking at land, I’ll start with what anyone who has spent real time with it will tell you. Valuing land is an art, not a science.
Houses come with a shared vocabulary: square feet, bedrooms, age, condition. You can line three up and argue about the differences. Land resists that. Appraisers work from sales of similar parcels, and with land, “similar” is doing a lot of work. Two parcels with the same acreage can sit a mile apart and be entirely different things.
The range is wide. At one end, a small lot, well under an acre, where every foot of setback matters. At the other, parcels measured in tens or hundreds of acres, where the question stops being how much room you have and becomes what you intend to do with it and what it’s going to take to be able to realize that vision.
But size is only the first number. Acreage tells you how much land there is. It doesn’t tell you how much of it you can use. A ten-acre parcel can hold a lovely building site or a very large wetland, or both, in proportions the listing won’t mention. Setbacks from water, wetlands, and boundaries shrink the footprint you can build on. Soil and granite deposits decide where a septic system can go, and sometimes whether one can. A parcel on a maintained road and a parcel reached by an unmaintained town road are different conversations with different people. A conservation easement or a current use enrollment changes what the land can do and what it costs to carry.
Then there’s the shape of the ground. A gentle south-facing slope. A flat clearing. A steep hillside with a view that makes every buyer go quiet. Slope shapes where a driveway can go, what a foundation costs, how water moves through mud season, and what you see from the window. Flat isn’t automatically better. Steep isn’t automatically worse. Ledge is either a feature or a line item, and you don’t really find out which until someone starts digging. Which means land is a risk, always, in a way a house with a title history and inspections just isn’t.
None of this is beyond discoverable or too much to handle. It just doesn’t all fit in a listing field. The MLS has a box for acres. It doesn’t have a box for “buildable, with a lot of money and some controlled blasting.” So a price per acre posited without a walk through the property or a professional survey is the beginning of an answer, not the end of one. I can show you what’s sold, and what it cost, and even what neighboring parcels were like, and I will. But I can’t guarantee how your build will go once the heavy equipment starts doing its job. I’d rather give you the complicated version than a tidy one that falls apart at the property line.
Allowed, able, and who shows up
A house you hope to rent and a lot you hope to build on are asking the same question in different languages: what is this place allowed to be, and what is it able to be?
Rules decide the first. Ground decides the second. The people decide what it feels like to live there. Right now the rules are being worked out in planning board meetings, the ground gets worked out one walk and one bucketful at a time, and the people part is decided every day, by whether anyone knows anyone on the road and who you wave to going into the post office.
If you’re thinking through buying a place you’d rent part of the time, or a piece of land you’re not sure how to read, I’m always happy to talk. Even if you’re just thinking out loud.
Here’s to having neighbors you wave to.
🧭Jenn
Keys to the Lakes.



